Administrative agencies of the American Federal Government since the passage of the 14th Amendment, have excluded foreigners and their children by race, creed, and color. As an example, that includes the total abolition of Chinese (The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882) and Japanese (Asian Exclusion Act of 1924) from becoming United States citizens. 

Calvin Coolidge was reluctant to sign Congress's Bill into law. 17 years later, Congress was vindicated when the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor.

This brings great skepticism to the current debate raging in America, as today, we find the opposite interpretations of these same Amendments and Supreme Court decisions from the 1860s and 1880s, respectively, to mean that open borders are a human right.

Advocates claim that anyone can cross the U.S. border—legally or illegally—drop their spawn, and add that child to the American taxpayer’s burden forever. No questions asked or allowed by Progressive fanatics of the Administrative State or Mainstream Media—both of which once held the opposing view.

In fact, the same political party which decried this “Birthright Citizenship” as ‘an outrage’ as recently as 1993 (Democrat Senate Majority Leader, Harry Reid), when it was not working in their favor, now holds “Birthright Citizenship” to be a sacrosanct human right.

Invaders, terrorists, people sworn to kill us all—if they can get across America’s porous borders for that moment of birth—that child is to be supported forever by U.S. taxpayers.

This madness prompted me to study the issue in depth and try to figure out how this policy could possible exist. It is admittedly an emotional, politically-driven debate, whose players keep switching sides, depending on the politics of the time—but they’re all wrong.

The facts, a little-used tool in American debate today, reveal a more sensible truth.

FACT—It is true that the Fourteenth Amendment granted the right for those born in the United States to become citizens, as a means of forcing the instatement of citizenship for black Americans born on American soil (a concept known as jus soli ) who were formerly victims of enslavement.

FACT— That same Amendment did not apply to Native Americans—and interestingly enough—it only recognized men. The girls were excluded, which indicates that considerable limitations were intended by the Republican Congress that proposed it. Ruth Bader Ginsburg recently acknowledged this uncomfortable truth in an interview—during which she forgot what the Fourteenth Amendment, was about but was reminded when a member of the audience gave her a copy of the Constitution she swore to uphold. 

FACT—Just two months before the adoption of the 14th Amendment in 1866, Congress also passed the Civil Rights Act to address the same issues and declared “all persons born in the United States and not subject to any foreign powers, excluding Indians not taxed” to be citizens.

If Congress did not intend for the original owners of America’s vast landscape to be citizens, the unlimited application of this idea today by so-called Progressives in both parties, seems a bit of a stretch. 

Further, the phrase ‘subject to foreign powers’ clearly excludes any who come to the United States illegally as they are still subject to ‘foreign powers’—the nation from which they came.

But the hard hike uphill to the truth gets even trickier, as the last seminal decision on this issue harkens back to Supreme Court decision Wong Kim Ark from 1898, when the court ruled that since Wong Kim Ark was born to parents who were in America legally at his time of birth, he was, in fact, a U.S. citizen, even though the law at that time did not recognize citizenship for his entire race.

The “Kim” ruling of 1898 decided that:

‘Upholding the concept of jus soli (citizenship based on place of birth),[116] the Court held that the Citizenship Clause needed to be interpreted in light of English common law,[117] which had included as subjects virtually all native-born children, excluding only those who were born to foreign rulers or diplomats, born on foreign public ships, or born to enemy forces engaged in hostile occupation of the country's territory.’[118][119][120] The ruling further required birth citizens to have “a permanent domicile and residence in the United States.”

Even the most elastic interpretation of this ruling would indicate that people illegally invading to occupy even a square meter of the country’s territory would qualify for exclusion from ever holding legal status or their children having any birthright to citizenship, but the further requirement to have “residence” in the United States is a legal term meaning that the parents must hold lawful status to reside in the nation, which is inescapable. Simply sneaking across the border or setting one foot on U.S. soil to make their offspring a citizen does not qualify. This should end the question for all times—but that is not likely, as immigration is the only life raft keeping the ‘Progressive’ Democrat Party afloat in America today.

President Trump, given the seriousness of this issue and the ineptness of the legislature to act on it, has promised an executive action—which will be immediately challenged by his opposition in the life raft and the mainstream media that does most of that party’s paddling.

 The President therefore needs to prepare for the inevitable court battle to prevent any of the invading ‘caravans’ from ever becoming residents or citizens by focusing on their stated intent to wilfully violate U.S. borders and determine them to be “enemy forces engaged in hostile occupation of the country’s territory.”

This 7,000 strong force of mostly young men between the ages of 18 and 24 have already broken through/invaded/violated the borders of either one or two nations, depending on whether they are Honduran or Guatemalan—and how Bangladeshis and Syrians came to be among them is yet to be determined.

Violently breaking through international borders, tearing down barricades and openly and notoriously violating the laws of Nations, while admittedly on the way to do so in yet a third or fourth nation to literally steal benefits, qualifies as ‘hostile’ and when financed by America’s enemies, it is rightly described as a force with ill intent.

It was also revealed this week that molotov cocktails (gasoline bombs) are being produced to be used at Mexico’s Southern border by the next group of invaders, and weapons are being provided by forces hostile to America, for a confrontation at the destination border—that of the United States.

The funding for this 7,000 strong force is, therefore, quite relevant. The money is now known to have come from two Marxist dictators ‘hostile’ to the United States. The President of Honduras officially advised U.S. Vice-President, Mike Pence this week that his government can prove that the money is coming from the Marxist regimes of Nicolás Maduro (Venezuela) and Miguel Díaz-Canel (Cuba) to fund this mercenary force marching on the United States.

A child gleaning for food on a rubbish tip in oil rich Venezuela. Let's make Socialism history.

This is actually a brilliant move in my opinion, and even though I abhor the use of poor people as pawns in a dangerous game of global politics by foreign dictators, that is nothing new for Marxist or even America’s own Oligarch and Socialist Presidents in recent invasions of other nations—which cost the U.S. taxpayers trillions of dollars.

These Marxist are much more efficient than Bush and Obama were, and I do admire that, while still holding their actions in utter contempt.

For the cost of less than one bomb, these two dictators will cost the American taxpayers 1) hatred from the world community, Globalists, Democratic Socialists of America/Democrat Party, and even the global Mainstream Media and 2) they will impose a financial burden on the American taxpayers for a century.

This is brilliant—they are undermining their enemy, for a pittance. If their cause was for actual freedom, rather than Marxist oppression, I’d be their greatest advocate—but they are not for that. They are simply using poor, oppressed people to further their Marxist ideology and bankrupt America.

The parents of six children travelling in the caravan are suing Trump.They claim that he "continues to abuse the law, including constitutional rights, to deter Central Americans from exercising their lawful right to seek asylum in the United States".

So what will this current Marxist-funded invasion cost the U.S. taxpayer? Hispanic columnist, Sara Gonzales, recently reported on the pricetag of illegal immigration alone—with does not include those who enter that nation legally, and it is staggering:

“The Federation for American Immigration Reform — or FAIR — released a comprehensive report Wednesday on the rising cost of illegal immigration. Here are the numbers you should know:

Total government expenditures on illegal immigration: $134.9 billion per year

Total federal costs: $45.9 billion

? Education costs: $1.7 billion

? Medical costs: $17.1 billion

? Justice system costs: $13.1 billion

? Welfare programs: $5.9 billion

? General expenditures: $8.1 billion

Total state and local costs: $89 billion

? Education costs: $44.4 billion

? Medical costs: $12.2 billion

? Justice system costs: $10.9 billion

? Welfare costs: $2.9 billion

? General expenditures: $18.6

Though many immigration advocates believe these expenditures are offset by the taxes paid into the system by illegal immigrants, FAIR’s report shows that even when considering total taxes paid by illegal immigrants at both federal and local levels, the deficit is staggering, with the costs outweighing the taxes paid into the system by a 7-to-1 ratio.”

If someone successfully breaks into my home, that does not automatically make them a part of my family. If someone successfully breaks into my nation, that does not make them—or their child—my fellow citizen.

Both are criminals—for whom I have great sympathy, as my writings attest—but I do not defend those who intentionally violate the laws of nations—or the sanctity of my home, in fact, and I very much equate the two.

All the President actually needs to do is declare this invasion as that of a ‘hostile force’ and he is covered. He can stop them, arrest them, imprison them, and send them back, with prejudice—meaning they can never return again or be considered for entry into the United States—and neither can any nappy-wearers they disgorge during their stay on President Trump’s soil.

This is not an issue that affects only America, but all countries. Are we to allow any and all to invade our sovereign nations, because they have allowed their own leaders to impose less successful policies and stultifying ideologies on them at home?

We should not. People need to sort out their own governments, not just flee to those that used human freedom and its inevitable results to their benefit.

Get rid of your own dictators, and put those ideas to work where you are.

Howell W. Woltz

Warsaw, Poland

3515
Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
2193 Comment threads
1322 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
153 Comment authors
.IQardeotisaustralisDucktracyCSBHotrocks Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
Notify of
ardeotisaustralis
Member
ardeotisaustralis

Dogs & models.

Hotrocks
Member
Hotrocks

:-))

oldskankhidinginTheShadow
Member
oldskankhidinginTheShadow

Monday, Monday, so good to me; Monday morning, it was all I hoped it would be. Oh, Monday morning, Monday morning couldn’t guarantee That Monday evening you would still be here with me. Monday, Monday, can’t trust that day; Monday, Monday, sometimes it just turns out that way. Oh, Monday morning, you gave me no warning of what was to be. Oh, Monday, Monday, how could you leave and not take me? Every other day, every other day Every other day of the week is fine, yeah. But whenever Monday comes – but whenever Monday comes You can find me… Read more »

Shylock
Member
Shylock

All I asked for was some Irish Jokes. Shalom.

TonyH
Member
TonyH

Throw a bit of burley and they bite!

noucg
Member
noucg

Hunter ,yes they damn well should taking the Government to task in failing in their Duty of Care ,allowing these potential terrorists on the streets ,maybe there should be a Class Action against the Government for letting these C…ts in ,in the first place .we dont want them ,we dont need them ,and what the hell are they doing here anyway ? a ”Tool” to be used by the PTB ,to bring in More restrictive Laws on the General Public etc ?

Shylock
Member
Shylock

Yep….agitators like Noel Ignatiev and Barbara Lerner Spectre

noucg
Member
noucg

If they complain they are called NAZIS’S

GeorgeofMagpie
Member
GeorgeofMagpie

The UK is fxxked .
Brexit 20 years too late

dante
Member
dante

Loose Cannon Harpo. Got me stuffed why people vote for him. The State is awash with Money from Taxes, Stamp Duty on Properties and Speeding Fines and he is blowing it away on his pet projects. Trouble is the Lib guy is a joke so there we have it.

GeorgeofMagpie
Member
GeorgeofMagpie

NEW POST up bt Harry

GeorgeofMagpie
Member
GeorgeofMagpie

More around 800,000 I’ve read .. That makes approx 8000 brainwashed jihadi’ lying in wait to murder us

Bwana
Donor
Bwana

Terry Mccrann rips into the turd and Keating.
Paul Keating and Malcolm Turnbull: a basket of delusionals.
Read in REPLIES

paisley
Member
paisley

This wanker Macron says the EU should have an army that protects itself from the USA, and Trump tells him where to go. If it were not for the USA, UK, Australia etc etc this piece of shit would be speaking German.
There are a few in Brussels HQ that the UK should tell the same story. What a pack of ungrateful bastards. The UK should now send Germany the war bill (Billions of dollars.) which they did not deliver after the war.

ejada
Donor
ejada

Annie Mac, That was supposed to be, ” Most of the 1.8 Billion Muslims HAVEN’T read the Qur’an”. Not sure what happened. I proof read it but not well enough obviously. Thanks for spotting that obvious error.

Ducktracy
Member
Ducktracy

Please brace yourself. This is the most demonic thing. Evil pure evil. The new Planned Parenthood ad AP Action Fund.

https://twitter.com/KayaJones/status/1061183065584615425

iamok
Member
iamok

About bloody time.

BlackRoo
Member
BlackRoo

Hunter, you need to send those questions to your local federal member AND the PM. Seriously, very good points. The whole Islamic shit makes me ill.

Farcanal
Member
Farcanal

Wanker!

JCM
Member
JCM

Well well well just heard on the news radio Billy shortarse want’s a referendum yes or no vote on becoming a Republic,arsewipe must want his mate Turdbull to be the first president

Edwin
Donor
Edwin

“widespread criticism on social media and from some officials in Britain ” wow..rock solid….Lock him up then.

ani-mal
Member
ani-mal

This is the result of leftist indoctrination AKA our education system. Thanks Julia, and all the other leftist areseholes who came before you. The name Whitlam comes to mind. Slowly erode and destroy any sense of national pride and your culture will eventually be taken over by another culture that really believes in it’self, like ISLAM…. The peoples of Australia were never asked to vote on our immigration policy.. A policy that is changing the very fabric of our society. Diversity is a complete scam, as is multiculturalism as a whole.

BlackRoo
Member
BlackRoo

So French President Macron is now looking at a European Army. Macron said Europe needed to protect itself against China, Russia “and even the United States”.

Kaiser
Member
Kaiser

Yes Cats, even that murdering black Muslim scumbag in Melbourne was somehow all Trumps fault.

ani-mal
Member
ani-mal

The pricks in charge must be held to account AT SOME FUTURE point in time

ani-mal
Member
ani-mal

All good. People who are net tax recipients. NO VOTE! Public servants HALF a vote!

attycats
Member
attycats

Macron has his finger firmly stuck up his arse, and it’s Trumps fault??? Every thing is now Trumps fault, even tomorrows rain.

Hotrocks
Member
Hotrocks

Bugger off , sloppy brian .

1rdoval@gmail.com
Member
1rdoval@gmail.com

Discuss? OK, I’ll give it a shot . . .

Joules was the first female prime minister of Australia, but some people didn’t like her because they’re just horrible misogynists who falsely accused her of stealing money from a union to make her house pretty.

Happy42
Member
Happy42

Scott Morrison would not lose one solitary vote if he was to refuse to sign the UN migration accord. Like that bearded clown at Malcolm Turnbull’s QandA, anyone who would refuse to vote for him over that wasn’t going to vote for him already.

Hotrocks
Member
Hotrocks

The young policeman who shot the terrorist in Vic the other day should be made Commissioner . He has skin in the game . ashton should be drummed out .

vecchio
Member
vecchio

Because it was hazardous for helicopter flights, seems a good enough reason?

AnnieMac
Guest
AnnieMac

We must NEVER forget!

pelican
Member
pelican

more lies from the Defence Brass in Canberra..initially ‘.Afghanistan is a training exercise – we are not fighting anyone…’…repeated after 5 years…and after 10 years………now The Afghanistan War is commemorated at the Australian War Memorial…with various recipients of the Victoria Cross now …for a ‘training exercise’ – oh yeah to bring democracy…real purpose…protect Jimmy Choo opium crops (which were being destroyed by the Taliban)…Australia..part of the world wide drug Jimmy Choo trafficking mafia..meanwhile our own Zio Government bans us from safe pain killers like codeine..for our own protection of course…all those who still believe – raise your hands…

pelican
Member
pelican

we’ve been conned…11/11….9/11….etc……all wars Aussies have been involved in from the Boer War onwards…was to kill Christians(Dutch Christian Orthodox Afikaaners, Christian (mainly Catholic( Germans, ) (or innocents in the case of Vietnam and Korea) and promote Zio Jimmy Choo Supremacy.by stealing land and or resources…at no point have we ever fought for ‘OUR freedom’..in fact we’re a lot less free than we were just over 100 years ago…all very unpalatable…but not as bad as the enslavement we currently suffer under…

Ducktracy
Member
Ducktracy

Melbourne #Terror #FakeNews @7NewsMelbourne

https://twitter.com/ARJ1807/status/1060835616177348608

TonyH
Member
TonyH

myxomatosis?

TonyH
Member
TonyH

When there are no votes in it for them!

TonyH
Member
TonyH

Count, or adjust?

pelican
Member
pelican

Mont..yes that is how the Vic/Feds are pulling these stunts….hupnosis and trigger points…it is shocking ..its also interesting that one of the people did his research in Sydney

TonyH
Member
TonyH

The day of reckoning will come one day Dis, and certain leftist will regret stirring the shit! History has proven that agitators suffer deservedly when retribution is commenced.

Panda
Member
Panda

The nerve of the RAPIST Billy Two Tits showing up in Melbourne to get a photo shot and Media rant cashing in with the Terrorist Attack…………………Me me and More ME!! Just arrest him………………..

snowgirl
Guest
snowgirl

And don’t forget the women whose men never came back. One of my mother’s aunts was engaged to someone who went to the war. He never came, and she never married, because there were so few available men.

I also will be attending the service in Sydney today.

1 42 43 44